• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar

The K-Var ArmoryThe K-Var Armory

The Largest Supplier of Firearms, Gun Parts, & Accessories Online

  • Shop K-Var
  • News
    • Industry
    • Politics
    • Second Amendment
    • Self Defense
    • Comics
  • Reviews
    • Anything AK
    • Anything AR
    • Gear
    • Pistols
    • Rifles
    • Shotguns
  • Newsletter

Smith and Wesson Versus Colt — Old Iron at its Best

October 16, 2019 by David Dolbee 6 Comments

When Samuel Colt invented the revolver as we know it, he turned the handgun world on its nose. Most handguns were horse pistols or pocket guns similar in design to rifles, they were simply shorter. The Colt revolver had to be designed to stabilize the firing hand to allow thumb cocking and to present the sights for proper aiming. Either way, this article details Old Iron at its best!

Bob Campbell shooting a 1917 .45 caliber Smith and Wesson N frame revolver
The author considers this 1917 .45 caliber Smith and Wesson N frame revolver among his frontline working handguns.

The Colt revolver was an offensive firearm and a credible military firearm that hastened the western movement. In short, it was an immensely important invention. Smith and Wesson’s original handgun was a lever-action design that led to the Winchester repeating rifle, but that is another story. By the time of the Civil War both Smith and Wesson and Colt were manufacturing viable revolver designs.

After the war, both companies manufactured distinctive revolvers. The hinged frame, and later break top, Smith and Wesson revolvers competed with Colt’s solid frame revolvers. The Colt sold better domestically while Smith and Wesson armed Russia and Japan among other armies. During the 1880s Colt began development of swing out cylinder double action revolvers that would bring the two companies’ products much closer in design and appearance.

Colt’s revolvers such as the New Pocket featured a swing out cylinder, cylinder latch that pulled to the rear, and a smooth double action trigger. Smith and Wesson followed suit with the Hand Ejector, a similar size .32 caliber revolver. The Colt .32 Long is smaller in diameter than the .32 Smith and Wesson Long and will not interchange. At this point in time, the companies were producing revolvers that in many ways were more similar than they differed.

five-shot .38 J Frame revolver
The five-shot .38 J Frame is among the revolvers that put Smith and Wesson at the top.

In a few years, there was another strong unifying moment in the handgun world. Previously, there had been proprietary cartridges for each maker. The .32 Colt, .32 Smith and Wesson, .38 Colt, and .38 Smith and Wesson were among these. In general, the .32 and .38 Colt cartridges were smaller and would chamber in the S&W chambers, but the cartridge case often split on firing. A big change occurred with the introduction of the Smith and Wesson Military and Police .38 revolver.

The .38 Colt was a dismal failure in action in the Philippines and at home. The U.S. Army asked for a revolver more robust than the Colt 1892 and a more powerful cartridge. Smith and Wesson lengthened the .38 Long Colt cartridge slightly and improved performance from a 152-grain bullet at 750 fps to a 158-grain bullet at 850 fps. The .38 Special became the most popular revolver cartridge of all time. The older .38s were eclipsed.

While the Colt Single Action Army remained popular past its prime, the primary spear point of competition for the two makers was in double action .38 Special revolvers. They traded in the top position in sales for some 50 years. During the 1930s the race was real with Colt having an edge. By the 1970s Smith and Wesson carried three quarters of the police market.

Two old Smith and Wesson revolvers
The S&W Perfected Double Action and Safety Hammerless are over 120 years old and still function well, despite years of use.

Many felt Smith and Wesson had the edge when they reinvested war time profits in new machinery and models after World War II. Colt introduced some models such as the Python, but Smith and Wesson introduced more models at more attractive prices. Eventually, Smith and Wesson enjoyed a considerable price advantage over Colt for similar handguns.

When I was growing up during the 1960s and beginning a lifelong interest in revolvers, my grandfather expressed a common opinion. He told me that he would not flip for the difference between the two. His favorite revolver was a Smith and Wesson Military and Police, but he liked the Colt Detective Special better than the Smith and Wesson Chief’s Special. I have pretty much the same preference.

I think that while the revolvers looked similar and handled the same, there were differences in the grip and trigger action that had appeal to different shooters. The price point and good performance made Smith and Wesson the leader. There were many excellent revolvers manufactured during the heyday of this competition. The Combat Masterpiece, Shooting Master, Target Masterpiece, Trooper, Highway Patrolman, Python, Detective Special, Chief’s Special, Cobra, Python and Combat Magnum were among them. Adjustable sights, ramp front sights, shrouded ejector rods, target triggers and hammers, trigger stops, and red insert front sights were introduced. Just the same, the revolver manufactured in the greatest numbers was the plain, vanilla, Military and Police revolver.

Young woman shooting the Smith and Wesson Combat Magnum revolver
The Smith and Wesson Combat Magnum is among the best balanced and fast handling of all revolvers.

The differences in the revolvers were seldom based on quality of manufacture. While each may have had an occasional bad run, this was rare. There were high points of production for each company. The Smith and Wesson Combat Magnum was probably the best-balanced revolver of all time. Light enough for constant carry, durable in long use, accurate, smooth in operation, and firing the best man stopper we are likely to invent, this .357 Magnum revolver was a prestige revolver.

The shrouded ejector rod and high visibility sights were important advantages. The K frame .38 has a skinny frame for use with Magnums, but the development of target stocks and rubber recoil absorbing stocks went a long way toward taming magnum recoil.

The Colt action differed, and while smooth enough, the Colt was the more likely to go out of time after hard use. The Colt revolver’s cylinder rotates right into the frame, the Smith and Wesson to the left, and the rifling is also different. Today, those who appreciate old iron are happy to find either revolver at a fair price.

Old Colt revolver and Colt 1911 pistol
Colt’s have some eye appeal and it isn’t difficult to make up a matching pair with the 1911 and the SAA.

The heyday of the revolver may be over as far as law enforcement is concerned. But many of us find the revolver suits our needs well. Most are highly accurate and offer plenty of power. When I am hiking or traveling around Appalachia, the Blue Ridge, and the Smokies, I sometimes find myself in the vicinity of feral dogs and other dangerous wildlife. The big cats are sometimes aggressive—I will never forget that my grandmother’s cousin, a small child, was killed by a panther in the early 1920s. Fifty years later she recounted the story as if it were yesterday.

I like something on my hip in the wild. A heavy loaded .38 Special or a .357 Magnum revolver just feels right. Will the revolver be a Colt or a Smith and Wesson? I own and enjoy both, more Colts than Smiths and would hate to part with either. Just the same, the gun on the hip is usually a Colt Python.  But sometimes, it is a Colt Single Action Army .45 or a beautifully smooth Colt .357. I guess we know who won the battle with me but lost the war.

Do you have a piece of Old Iron that tops your list of favorite handguns? Share it in the comment section.

Top to bottom — A Colt Army Special, Colt .357 and a rare Colt Detective Special with three-inch barrel.
Top to bottom — A Colt Army Special, Colt .357 and a rare Colt Detective Special with three-inch barrel.
Smith and Wesson J frame five-shot .38
The J frame five-shot .38 is arguably one of the revolvers that put Smith and Wesson on the top.
factory-tuned Smith and Wesson L frame revolver
A factory-tuned Smith and Wesson L frame is a joy to use and fire.
Old Colt revolver and Colt 1911 pistol
Colt’s have some eye appeal and it isn’t difficult to make up a matching pair with the 1911 and the SAA.
The Colt Cobra, top, and the Smith and Wesson Model 13, bottom
The Colt Cobra, top, and the Smith and Wesson Model 13, bottom are each fine all-around defensive revolvers.
Colt Army Special revolver
The Colt Army Special had the barrel cut at some time in the past, it was re-purposed as a snake charmer.
revolver with the swing out cylinder in the open position
Once Colt perfected the swing out cylinder revolver the stage was set for revolvers for a hundred years to come.
Smith and Wesson .357 Magnum revolver
The Smith and Wesson .357 Magnum was the first magnum and a classic handgun with excellent performance.
Bob Campbell shooting a 1917 .45 caliber Smith and Wesson N frame revolver
The author considers this 1917 .45 caliber Smith and Wesson N frame revolver among his frontline working handguns.
Young woman shooting the Smith and Wesson Combat Magnum revolver
The Smith and Wesson Combat Magnum is among the best balanced and fast handling of all revolvers.
Two old Smith and Wesson revolvers
The S&W Perfected Double Action and Safety Hammerless are over 120 years old and still function well, despite years of use.
five-shot .38 J Frame revolver
The five-shot .38 J Frame is among the revolvers that put Smith and Wesson at the top.

Sign up for K-Var’s weekly newsletter and discounts here.

Filed Under: Colt, Pistols, Revolvers, Smith and Wesson Tagged With: .357 Magnum, .38 Special, .45 Colt, Colt, double action, Home Defense, hunting, personal defense, Revolvers, Smith and Wesson

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. BillB says

    October 18, 2019 at 4:20 pm

    I’d love to have a Colt Python but they’ve become insanely priced for me. I did get a Colt DSII that’s very nice though. Picking one of what I have it would be a 686+ or even a Ruger Match Champion.

    Reply
  2. Joe Neary says

    October 18, 2019 at 9:52 pm

    I’ve only owned one Colt and it was a 6 inch Python, which I didn’t use as I got it at a local gun auction. Consequently I sold it for more than I paid, but now wish I’d kept it just for the value aspect. I am a retired P.O. and was weened on S&W. I still have most all of the Smiths I used and still carry.( 4″ Model 19, 2″ Model 60, 6″ Model 66. a Model 669 9mm, sadly sold a 4″ Model 686, and a 4″ Model 29,) My Newer S&W’s are a 6″ 686 Custom Shop model, never fired, an M&P 9c, M&P 9, M2,0 ,5″ never fired , M&P Bodyguard .380 carry piece, M&P Shield 9, M&P Shield 9 from the pro shop, never fired, M&P Shield 9 M 2.0 with Crimson Trace laser, Carry Piece. Plus an M&P 15, NATO, and on and on. I guess you could say I Love Smith and Wesson Firearms.
    Qualified as a Pistol Expert, and love the way they feel and shoot.

    Reply
  3. william s Palmer says

    October 19, 2019 at 6:21 am

    I own several different S&W revolvers,especially snubbies! I like the Colt,but the prices are out of control, and not worth it to me. The Colt s a nice piece,but not that nice.

    Reply
  4. Larry says

    October 19, 2019 at 7:07 am

    Years ago as a young cop. I was called to the station. An Officer whom I had met at a tri-state firearms meet the year before told me if he ever sold his Python, I would get first chance at it. In this case he was on his way to Mt for a new job. He said he remembered that I wanted his Python. I was broke and went to the bank and begged the banker for a $125.00 30 day loan. He agreed. When we went to his car he open the trunk and gave me the Nickle Plated 4 inch Python, a fancy tooled belt and holster, two boxes of ammo, a pair of handcuffs, and a can of del defend. The belt way too big for me I sold to my Chief for $20.00 . The Python I carried for years and finally passed on to my Son last year. I never shot it the last two years but still miss opening the drawer and seeing that beautiful sidearm but I know its in good hands.

    Reply
  5. Doug says

    October 19, 2019 at 9:08 pm

    I was lucky enough to acquire 2 Pythons some years back . Pricey then but nothing like they are today . I also picked up a 686 a couple years ago . All are great guns but the Pythons are my favorites . They’ll never leave the family . I made a comment to my wife once that if we were ever in a pinch the Pythons would bring good money . Her response…..” your ass !”

    Reply
  6. Chris in Texas says

    October 22, 2019 at 9:22 am

    My favorite revolver was a WWII era Enfield top break revolver in .455 cal. I used .45ACP in full moon clips and also a few ’45 Auto rim cartridges I found. I inherited the revolver from my dad and it had been given to him by my great-grandfather. I taught my children, and later, my step-children to shoot with that old .45. My home was broken into while no one was home and that wonderful old revolver is in someone else’s hands now but it will always be my favorite. Thanks for the article.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


The reCAPTCHA verification period has expired. Please reload the page.

Primary Sidebar

Subscribe to the Muzzle Flash – The K-Var Armory Official Newsletter!

* Required field
Marketing permission: I give my consent to to be in touch with me via email using the information I have provided in this form for the purpose of news, updates and marketing.

Recent Posts

  • Trump’s 50% Tariff Threat: Impact on Imported Firearm Prices
  • Circle 10 “Waffle Pattern” 30-round Magazine: As Good As it Gets
  • The LF308 Battle Rifle AR-10
  • Long Range Shooting 3
  • K-Var’s 180-Day Layaway Program: Own Your Dream Firearm, Interest-Free!
Gun Broker Auctions

Archives

  • May 2025
  • April 2025
  • March 2025
  • February 2025
  • January 2025
  • December 2024
  • November 2024
  • October 2024
  • September 2024
  • August 2024
  • July 2024
  • April 2024
  • March 2024
  • February 2024
  • January 2024
  • December 2023
  • November 2023
  • October 2023
  • September 2023
  • August 2023
  • July 2023
  • June 2023
  • May 2023
  • April 2023
  • March 2023
  • February 2023
  • January 2023
  • December 2022
  • November 2022
  • October 2022
  • September 2022
  • August 2022
  • July 2022
  • June 2022
  • May 2022
  • April 2022
  • March 2022
  • February 2022
  • January 2022
  • December 2021
  • November 2021
  • October 2021
  • September 2021
  • August 2021
  • July 2021
  • June 2021
  • May 2021
  • April 2021
  • March 2021
  • February 2021
  • January 2021
  • December 2020
  • November 2020
  • October 2020
  • September 2020
  • July 2020
  • June 2020
  • May 2020
  • April 2020
  • March 2020
  • February 2020
  • January 2020
  • December 2019
  • November 2019
  • October 2019
  • September 2019
  • August 2019
  • July 2019
  • June 2019
  • May 2019
  • April 2019
  • March 2019
  • February 2019
  • January 2019
  • December 2018
  • November 2018
  • October 2018
  • September 2018
  • August 2018
  • July 2018
  • June 2018
  • May 2018
  • April 2018
  • March 2018
  • February 2018
  • January 2018
  • December 2017
  • November 2017

Categories

  • 1911
  • Accessories
  • Ammunition
  • Anything AK
  • Anything AR
  • Arex
  • Arsenal
  • Blades
  • Browning
  • Cartridges
  • Charter Arms
  • Colt
  • Comics
  • Conservation
  • Dan Wesson
  • Deer
  • Derringer
  • Gear
  • Glock
  • Hearing Protection
  • Holsters
  • How To
  • How-To
  • Hunting
  • Industry
  • Kahr
  • Kel-Tec
  • Lasers
  • News
  • NFA
  • Night Vision
  • North American Arms
  • Op-ed
  • Optics
  • Optics
  • Pistols
  • Politics
  • Predator
  • Product Recall Notice
  • Red Dot
  • Reloading
  • Reviews
  • Revolvers
  • Rifles
  • Rimfire
  • Rock Island Armory
  • Rossi
  • Ruger
  • Ruger
  • Savage
  • Second Amendment
  • Self Defense
  • Shotguns
  • SIG Sauer
  • Small Game
  • Smith and Wesson
  • Springfield
  • Tactics
  • Taurus
  • Thermal
  • Turkey
  • Uncategorized
  • Video
  • Walther
  • Waterfowling
  • Comics
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms
  • About
  • Newsletter

Copyright © 2025 · K-Var Corp · Log in